Switching from Similac Advanced to Sensitive Formula

My wife has always hated Alexandria getting fussy from gas or what she suspects may be an upset tummy caused by her Similac Advance Formula. I have never really been convinced that there was a big problem.

If the baby was fussy, it would normally not be for more than about 15 or 20 minutes once or twice a day. The fussiness would usually end with a fart and a suddenly relaxed baby.

On one occasion, my wife was very concerned about how much the baby seemed to be straining. Realizing that we had a doctor’s appointment the next day, I grabbed our digital camera that can make short movie clips and filmed exactly what the baby was doing. I put the movie on my laptop and brought it to the doctor the next day.

Upon seeing the clip of the baby straining the doctor looked up and us and said “isn’t technology great?”. We replied, yes… do you see a problem? He thinks for a second and promptly replies “I’m not impressed by anything you just showed me”…

Hahaha. Unexpected, but very direct answer. He then explained that switching formula can often cause unexpected and undesired results and that a little fussiness a few times a day really didn’t justify changing formulas.

Instead he suggested we buy some baby gas drops like Little Tummys. They are basically baby Gas X. They collect all the little gas bubbles in the stomach and combine them into a bigger one and passes more easily and therefore, reduces bloating.

We’ve pretty much been addicted to them ever since. Alexandria still has come bouts of discomfort from time to time, but nothing terrible.

The problem is that it seems that the baby only has these bouts when we have relatives over. The relatives insist that we are hurting her by not switching formulas. They have the impression that she’s like that all the time.

Well, the pressure finally got to my wife. On an expedition to the baby store, she picked up a can of Similac Sensitive¬†formula saying “we’ll just try it”. A few days later, without my prior knowledge, wifey decided to make the switch. The results were disasterous.

The baby suddenly went from eating about every three hours to every hour to hour and a half. She was constantly hungry and fussy as if she just couldn’t get satisfied. She was also peeing constantly.

Wifey tried to keep this up all day long. I finally decided near bed time that it was time to switch back as I didn’t want either of us up every hour all night long. That made no sense at all.

My wife tried to give her the Similac Sensitive again the next day to see if maybe it was something else that made the baby insane with hunger. Nope. Same result.

We switched back to Similac Advance with Early Shield and haven’t looked back since. I know my wife is still secretly jones’in to switch formulas again, but I am not convinced.

Have any luck switching forumulas with your child? Did it work? Any advice? Please let us know with a comment below!

4 Responses to “Switching from Similac Advanced to Sensitive Formula”

  • I’m curious as to the outcome of your switch. Did you keep your baby on the Similac Sensitive or Similac Advance. I share your exact same story. Our baby is fussing maybe an hour out of the day and seems relieved when passing gas at times. I’ve switched today (10/19/090 to the Sim Sensitive and hope that I’m not making a mistake.
    On the early shield (Similac reg form) we’re only making it 3-4 hrs at night with our 5 week old. I didn’t know if the formula was causing this or not. I hope you can respond.

  • Sharon, you are actually doing really well making 3 – 4 hours a night at 5 weeks. Alexandria started making it most of the way through the night at two and a half to three months.

    Basically the baby’s stomach isn’t big enough to hold a lot of food and since her diet is all liquid, it passes within a few hours, hence the need to feed once or twice during the night.

    Once your baby gets big enough to hold more food in her tummy, she’ll make it longer stretches.

    As for the formula, we went back to the Similac Advance with early shield. For the gas, just try to do a good job burping your baby during feedings and try the little tummies gas drops. We swear by them.

    The Similac Sensitive I think just made things worse as it seems to have a thinner consistency that passes through the babies even faster than the regular.

    let me know how it goes!

  • We have our 3 month old on Similac Advance and we add Mylicon drops to each bottle. The drops alleviate almost all of his gas problems. My parents watch him during the day and my stepmom is against giving him the gas drops and refuses to give them to him, so she has to deal with him being super fussy all day. One day she decided (without notifying me) to switch his formula to the Similac Sensitive. He was fine the first two feedings, but when I got him back at the end of the day and I fed him one bottle of it, he threw up all over me and screamed until he burped. We stopped giving it to him after that. Also one day later he was completely constipated! Had I felt the need to switch his formula I would’ve talked to his doctor first. I agree with the doctor, you shouldn’t change the formula just because your baby has gas…ALL babies have gas!

  • Horrible day attempting to try similac sensitive! Right from the first bottle he was way mote fussy, hungry again in 1 hour and would not nap at all! I think I was being one of those moms that overreacts to a gassy fussy baby and I convinced myself that it was worse than it really was. Thinking about it now I realize that all babies are fussy and gassy at times and I need to relax! Went back to the similac advance tonight…hopefully that sensitive stuff is out of his system soon. I feel so bad for causing him discomfort today. :(

Leave a Reply

To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Anti-spam image